LINKS

KEYWORDS

Lost Poem Mystery
Climate Dystopia
Unreliable Memory
Academic Obsession
Dual Timeline

What We Can Know

by IAN MCEWAN

In a future Britain devastated by climate and nuclear catastrophe, academic Tom Metcalfe obsessively searches for a legendary lost poem from 2014, unraveling the tangled lives and secrets of its creator and his circle through digital archives. The novel explores the unreliability of memory, the construction of history, and the limits of what can truly be known about the past, ultimately questioning how narratives are shaped and whose truths endure.

Reader Review Summary

Set in a future Britain transformed into a series of islands by climate change and nuclear disaster, the novel follows Tom Metcalfe, an academic in 2119, as he obsessively researches a legendary lost poem, 'A Corona for Vivien,' written and performed once in 2014 by the poet Francis Blundy for his wife, Vivien. The narrative alternates between Tom’s quest—using archives, emails, and digital remnants to reconstruct the past—and a second section that shifts to Vivien’s own perspective, revealing the true events and relationships behind the poem and its disappearance. The story explores themes of memory, history, the reliability of records, and the ways in which the past is mythologized or misunderstood by future generations. The backdrop includes a detailed depiction of a post-catastrophe world, where the humanities are in decline, and the remnants of 21st-century culture are both treasured and distorted by those who survive.

Readers praised the novel’s intricate structure, especially the dual timelines and the interplay between the future historian’s reconstruction and the firsthand account from the past. Many found the exploration of memory, legacy, and the limits of historical knowledge compelling, with several noting the tension between romanticizing the past and confronting its realities. The writing style, described as dense and carefully constructed, was appreciated for its intellectual rigor and the way it mirrored the novel’s themes. The depiction of a future shaped by climate and nuclear disaster, as well as the detailed academic and archival research process, were highlighted as immersive and thought-provoking. The second half, which reveals Vivien’s perspective and upends earlier assumptions, was frequently cited as gripping and emotionally impactful.

Some readers found the first half of the novel slow, dense, or overly academic, with long passages that felt dry or difficult to engage with. The focus on poetry, archival research, and academic life in the future was off-putting for those less interested in these subjects, and several noted that the narrative sometimes resembled a research paper more than a novel. Characterization was another point of criticism: some found the main characters, especially Tom and Vivien, unlikable or emotionally distant, and felt that the novel’s treatment of certain characters—particularly women—was harsh or unbalanced. The climate and political commentary was described by a few as heavy-handed or didactic, and some readers were frustrated by the lack of a clear mystery or emotional payoff. A minority did not finish the book, citing boredom or disappointment with the narrative style and pacing.

In addition to its literary and speculative elements, the novel incorporates detailed world-building about the future’s technological, ecological, and geopolitical changes, including the collapse of fossil fuels, the impact of nuclear conflict, and the transformation of the UK’s geography. The structure includes metafictional elements, such as a fake author’s note, and references to literary forms like the sonnet corona. The book has drawn comparisons to works like 'Possession' by A.S. Byatt and 'Pale Fire' by Nabokov, and has prompted discussion about the preservation and interpretation of cultural artifacts. The reception has been mixed to positive, with an average rating of 3.88 out of 5 from 279 ratings and 158 full reviews, and the book is scheduled for publication in August 2025.

Other Books You Might Like


Copyright ©2024 Hidden Sci-Fi